top of page
fnlogo.png

Fierce Opposition Mounts Against South Africa’s Proposed 20% National Online Gambling Tax

1 hour ago
8 min read

South Africa’s proposed introduction of a 20% national tax on online gambling operators has triggered strong resistance from bookmakers, gambling companies, legal practitioners and industry representatives, with opponents warning that the measure could damage the regulated gambling sector, threaten employment, encourage illegal offshore betting and fail to address the underlying causes of problem gambling.


Gambling Tax

 

The proposal was the subject of heated debate during a National Treasury workshop held on Friday, where industry stakeholders challenged both the economic justification and the anticipated social benefits of imposing an additional national levy on online gambling revenue.

 

The proposed tax would be imposed on gross gambling revenue (GGR), representing the money retained by operators after paying out winnings. It would be introduced on top of existing provincial gambling taxes and other applicable taxes, potentially placing a substantially greater financial burden on licensed operators.

 

Some participants warned that the measure could have unintended consequences, including weakening legitimate domestic businesses while making unregulated offshore gambling platforms more attractive to South African customers.

 

The debate has also highlighted a fundamental disagreement over the government's approach to gambling-related harm: whether increasing taxation is an effective way of discouraging excessive gambling or whether more targeted interventions, stronger enforcement and better support services would produce more meaningful results.

 

Rising gambling participation raises concerns

The proposed tax comes against a background of rapidly increasing gambling participation in South Africa and mounting concerns about the social and financial consequences.

 

Professor Corné van Walbeek, head of the Research Unit on the Economics of Excisable Products at the University of Cape Town, highlighted research indicating that gambling participation doubled between 2017 and 2023, while problem gambling increased fivefold during the same period.

 

He also estimated that households were losing approximately R75 billion through gambling, illustrating the scale of the financial impact on South African consumers.

 

Van Walbeek acknowledged that the proposed national tax was not a comprehensive solution to the problem. However, he argued that it could send an important signal that the growth of gambling and its associated consequences require attention.

 

He described the levy as not being a “silver bullet”, while recognising that the proposal reflected legitimate concerns about the expansion of gambling activity.

 

His contribution underlined the difficult balance facing policymakers: gambling generates significant economic activity and government revenue, but excessive participation can impose substantial financial and social costs on individuals, families and communities.

 

Industry warns against reversing progress in regulated gambling

One of the principal arguments against the proposed tax concerns the potential damage to South Africa's regulated online betting market.

 

Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr (CDH), representing Hollywoodbets, argued that the rapid expansion of online gambling should be considered in the context of changes to the country's licensing environment.

 

According to Jerome Brink, tax director at CDH, provincial authorities had modernised online gambling licensing arrangements approximately three years ago. This helped encourage South African punters to move away from unregulated offshore gambling platforms towards locally licensed operators operating within a monitored and taxed environment.

 

The industry believes this transition represented an important regulatory achievement.

Brink warned that imposing a punitive additional tax on businesses that had entered the regulated system could undermine those gains and potentially encourage customers to return to offshore platforms.

 

The concern is that higher operating costs could affect the competitiveness of licensed domestic bookmakers. If operators respond by reducing promotional offerings, changing betting conditions or lowering the attractiveness of winnings, customers could increasingly seek alternatives outside the regulated market.

 

From the industry's perspective, the government risks weakening businesses that are already contributing to the formal economy while leaving less-regulated competitors in a stronger position.

 

Questions raised over the effectiveness of the proposed tax

The relationship between taxation and responsible gambling was another major point of disagreement.

 

Tamara Stork of Stork Attorneys, representing the Gauteng Off-Course Bookmakers Association, questioned whether National Treasury's discussion paper had established a sufficiently clear connection between imposing an additional tax and achieving a measurable reduction in irresponsible gambling.

 

She argued that the proposal focuses on taxing bookmakers rather than directly addressing the behaviour of individual gamblers.

 

In her view, increasing the tax burden on operators does not automatically mean that customers will gamble less or that harmful gambling behaviour will decline.

 

Stork maintained that government should first properly consider targeted interventions supported by evidence demonstrating their effectiveness before introducing a tax of such significant proportions.

 

Her argument raises an important policy question: whether a financial levy imposed on gambling businesses can realistically influence the behaviour of individuals experiencing compulsive gambling, particularly when those individuals may simply move to alternative platforms.

 

Responsible gambling experts highlight the psychological dimension

The South African Responsible Gambling Foundation also raised concerns about relying on taxation as a means of controlling gambling addiction.

 

Its executive director, Sibongile Simelane-Quntana, emphasised that compulsive gambling is not simply a matter of consumers making rational financial decisions.

 

She explained that the neurological mechanisms associated with problem gambling can override an individual's financial limits and encourage continued gambling, even when substantial losses have already occurred.

 

For people experiencing gambling addiction, increasing the financial pressure associated with gambling may not necessarily discourage participation.

 

Instead, it could intensify the desire to recover lost money or pursue further winnings.

Simelane-Quntana warned that additional costs do not necessarily reduce compulsive behaviour and could potentially escalate the urge to chase losses.

 

Her contribution highlighted the importance of understanding gambling addiction as a behavioural and psychological problem requiring appropriate treatment, prevention and support rather than assuming that higher taxation alone will resolve it.

 

Employment and investment concerns emerge

The potential economic consequences of the proposed levy were particularly emphasised by Sun International chief executive Ulrik Bengtsson.

 

He explained that the group's online gambling business, SunBet, forms an integral part of its broader business model and contributes to supporting its substantial workforce.

Sun International employs approximately 7,000 people and spends around R2 billion annually on salaries and wages.

 

The group also highlighted its wider economic contribution, including approximately R3 billion in gaming taxes, company tax and value-added tax.

 

Furthermore, Sun International has announced plans to invest approximately R6 billion in capital expenditure across South Africa over the following five years.

 

Against this background, the company raised serious concerns about the financial implications of the proposed national tax.

 

According to the figures presented, the additional levy would result in approximately R800 million in new tax obligations for Sun International and could reduce SunBet's profitability by around 70%.

 

Such a substantial reduction in profitability could have implications extending beyond the company's online gambling operations.

 

The concerns include the potential impact on employment, investment decisions, business expansion and the group's ability to maintain its contribution to the wider economy.

 

For the industry, the issue is therefore not simply whether companies would pay more tax, but whether the cumulative financial burden could undermine the sustainability of legitimate gambling businesses.


Gambling License

 

Legal expert questions the rationality of the proposal

Garron Whitesman, a legal expert at Whitesmans Attorneys, delivered particularly strong criticism of the proposed national levy.

 

He argued that the tax lacked a sufficiently sound evidential foundation and questioned whether it was rational or reasonable in light of its stated objectives.

 

Whitesman maintained that there was insufficient empirical evidence demonstrating that the proposed tax would achieve National Treasury's intended policy outcomes.

 

He also pointed to international examples, particularly the Netherlands, where significant increases in gambling taxation had reportedly failed to produce the additional revenue initially anticipated.

 

The Netherlands increased its gambling tax rate to approximately 37%, with authorities forecasting additional revenue of €108 million in 2025 and €216 million in 2026.

 

However, figures compiled by the Dutch gambling authority and finance minister reportedly showed that the actual revenue increases fell substantially short of those projections.

 

Revenue increased by only approximately €2 million in 2025 and €57 million in 2026.

 

Whitesman used the example to question the assumptions underpinning South Africa's proposal, arguing that higher tax rates do not necessarily translate into proportionately higher government revenue.

 

He warned that the proposal was fundamentally flawed and should not proceed in its current form.

 

His criticism extended to the proposed implementation timetable, with strong opposition to the possibility of introducing the measure in February 2027.

 

National Treasury acknowledges industry concerns but defends intervention

National Treasury deputy director-general for tax policy Christopher Axelson acknowledged the concerns raised by industry participants and indicated that the department would give further consideration to its economic modelling.

 

However, he maintained that the government had a responsibility to address the negative social consequences associated with gambling.

 

Axelson argued that intervention was justified, pointing to other countries that had introduced similar measures. He acknowledged that important questions remained concerning the appropriate structure of the tax, the rate at which it should be imposed and what would constitute a reasonable financial burden.

 

His position suggests that Treasury is not necessarily abandoning the proposal but remains open to considering adjustments to its design.

 

The department's central argument is that online gambling has expanded significantly and that the associated social costs justify government intervention.

 

In its original policy discussion, Treasury proposed a national tax on online gambling revenue as an additional mechanism for addressing the negative externalities associated with problem gambling. The proposal also seeks to establish a more unified national taxation framework for online gambling activities that extend beyond provincial boundaries.

 

Free Market Foundation challenges government's approach

Ayanda Zulu, policy officer at the Free Market Foundation, offered a different perspective on the government's proposed intervention.

 

Zulu argued that gambling-related social harm should be addressed through appropriate social interventions rather than relying primarily on government taxation.

 

His position was that the existence of problem gambling does not automatically justify introducing an additional tax on the industry.

 

He also cautioned gambling operators against defending the proposed tax by emphasising their existing tax contributions and arguing that government should instead concentrate on illegal gambling operators.

 

Although he recognised that the industry's response was understandable, Zulu warned that this approach could inadvertently legitimise the broader principle of increased state intervention in gambling.

 

He suggested that operators should consider the longer-term implications of accepting the premise that additional taxation is the appropriate mechanism for addressing gambling-related social problems.

 

His contribution introduced another dimension to the debate: the question of whether the industry should focus exclusively on opposing the proposed tax or challenge the underlying policy approach itself.

 

The wider policy debate

The opposition to the proposed levy reflects broader concerns about the balance between gambling regulation, taxation, consumer protection and economic sustainability.

 

For National Treasury, the argument is that online gambling has grown to a point where existing provincial taxation arrangements may not adequately address the wider social consequences of the industry.

 

For bookmakers and gambling operators, however, the additional tax could create an increasingly difficult operating environment, particularly when considered alongside existing provincial taxes and other statutory obligations.

 

There is also concern that the proposed measure could create an imbalance between licensed domestic businesses and offshore operators that may be difficult for South African authorities to monitor and regulate effectively.

 

The question of problem gambling remains central to the disagreement.

 

While the government maintains that intervention is necessary, industry representatives and other stakeholders argue that taxation should not be confused with effective addiction prevention.

 

They believe that addressing the underlying causes of harmful gambling behaviour requires a combination of responsible gambling programmes, targeted interventions, enforcement against illegal operators and accessible treatment services.

 

The debate also highlights the importance of ensuring that any additional tax revenue produces tangible benefits for society, particularly for people and families affected by gambling addiction.

 

A difficult decision ahead for government

The National Treasury workshop demonstrated the extent of opposition confronting the proposed national online gambling tax.

 

Industry representatives have raised concerns about profitability, employment, investment, competitiveness and the possibility of customers migrating towards illegal offshore platforms.

 

Legal practitioners have questioned the proposal's evidential and economic foundations, while responsible gambling specialists have highlighted the limitations of taxation as a tool for addressing compulsive gambling.

 

At the same time, Treasury maintains that the social consequences of the industry's rapid expansion require government intervention.

 

The challenge facing policymakers is to develop a framework that addresses legitimate concerns about gambling-related harm without inadvertently undermining the regulated industry or encouraging further growth in illegal gambling activity.

 

With the proposed February 2027 implementation timeline attracting considerable criticism, the coming months will be important in determining whether National Treasury maintains its original approach or revises the proposed tax following industry consultation.

 

Ultimately, the dispute is about more than the introduction of another tax. It concerns the future structure of South Africa's online gambling market, the responsibilities of government and operators, and the most effective way of protecting consumers from the financial and psychological consequences of problem gambling.

 

The central question remains whether a substantial additional tax will achieve the government's social objectives or create unintended economic and regulatory consequences that could make the problem even harder to control.

By fLEXI tEAM

Comments


bottom of page