Brazil’s Supreme Court Moves Closer to Broader Ruling on Gambling as Flávio Dino Releases Case for Review
Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court (STF) has taken another step towards resolving the country’s increasingly complex gambling regulatory debate after Justice Flávio Dino returned a major case concerning the legality of gambling operations to the court for further consideration.

On Thursday, November 12, Dino formally released the proceedings for the continuation of the trial, ending a period of suspension that began in August, when he requested additional time to examine the case. The dispute centres on whether the operation of gambling activities should continue to be classified as a criminal misdemeanour under Brazilian law.
Although Dino’s decision makes it possible for the proceedings to resume, the Supreme Court has not yet announced a date for the next hearing. The development is nevertheless significant because the case could become part of a much broader examination of gambling, sports betting, online gaming and state and municipal lottery operations in Brazil.
The possibility of bringing several related proceedings together reflects growing recognition within the court that the country's gambling framework can no longer be considered solely through the legal provisions adopted in the 1940s. Instead, the justices are increasingly confronted with questions arising from a modern betting industry that includes digital platforms, online casinos, sports wagering and new forms of lottery operation.
The legal dispute surrounding Brazil's 1941 gambling legislation
At the centre of the case is Article 50 of Brazil’s Law of Criminal Misdemeanours, established in 1941. The provision prohibits the establishment or operation of gambling activities in Brazil and provides for penalties ranging from three months to one year of simple imprisonment, in addition to a financial fine.
The legislation covers different forms of gambling and has remained an important element of Brazil's legal framework despite the substantial technological, economic and regulatory changes that have taken place since its introduction.
The constitutional question before the STF is whether this provision remains compatible with Brazil's 1988 Federal Constitution and should therefore continue to be enforced.
The proceedings originated from a legal dispute involving a gambling-related case in Rio Grande do Sul. A lower court had rejected the application of the criminal provision, concluding that the prohibition was incompatible with constitutional principles introduced in 1988.
The Public Prosecutor's Office of Rio Grande do Sul subsequently challenged that interpretation, bringing the matter before the Supreme Court.
Justice Luiz Fux, who serves as rapporteur, had already voted in favour of maintaining the punishment established under the 1941 legislation. His position supports the continued validity of the prohibition, meaning that gambling operations covered by the provision would remain subject to criminal penalties.
Dino requested additional time to consider the matter in August, when the court was discussing whether the dispute should be examined alongside other proceedings concerning the Brazilian betting industry.
The decision to return the case now reopens the possibility of a ruling, although the timing and precise format of the next stage remain undecided.
Supreme Court considers bringing gambling-related cases together
The question of whether the 1941 prohibition remains valid has become increasingly connected to other legal challenges involving Brazil's gambling market.
On November 4, the STF Plenary indicated that it could consider a coordinated examination of several cases covering gambling, municipal lotteries, sports betting and online gaming.
The discussion took place during proceedings concerning ADPF 1212 (Claim of Non-compliance with a Fundamental Precept), which examines whether Brazilian municipalities have the constitutional authority to establish and operate their own lotteries, including sports lotteries.
During the session, Dino reiterated his preference for a joint examination of the different cases. He argued that the legal questions were interconnected and that the court should seek a broader understanding of the sector rather than deliver separate decisions that might fail to address the wider regulatory implications.
Justice Luiz Fux, who is responsible for the proceedings concerning the betting legislation as well as RE 966177, supported the possibility of coordinating the cases.
The court's president, Justice Edson Fachin, also indicated that the STF could move towards organising a joint session, although the proceedings had initially been expected to be considered separately.
Fachin acknowledged that the direction of the court's planning could change following the arguments presented by the justices and other participants.
Commenting on the possibility, he stated:
“The Presidency's initial inclination is towards separate trials. However, I am obviously open to the considerations of the other members of the court and, given what we have seen here, including some oral arguments referring to yesterday's public hearing, perhaps this could eventually become the way forward.”
Fux, meanwhile, highlighted the need for additional preparation time to develop an opinion that would address all the legal questions raised across the different proceedings.
The potential joint examination is therefore not simply an administrative decision about scheduling. It could determine how the Supreme Court approaches the relationship between traditional gambling prohibitions, the regulation of modern betting platforms and the constitutional powers of different levels of government.
Dias Toffoli highlights the changing nature of gambling
Justice Dias Toffoli has also supported a broader approach to the cases, arguing that the legal debate must take account of the significant changes that have transformed the gambling industry.
His position reflects the view that the existing legislation cannot be examined in isolation from the development of online gaming, digital betting platforms and other contemporary gambling products.
During the discussions, Toffoli stressed that the issue extends well beyond the original provisions of the Misdemeanours Act.
He stated:
“It is not just about the Misdemeanour Act. It is a new, complex, and difficult world; it is not the world of the 1940s.”
The statement captures one of the central challenges facing the Supreme Court: determining how legislation drafted more than eight decades ago should be interpreted in an environment where gambling is increasingly conducted through digital platforms and sophisticated technological systems.
Toffoli's intervention also reinforces the argument that the court should consider the broader social and economic implications of gambling rather than focus exclusively on the technical validity of a single legal provision.
New provisional measure adds another dimension to the dispute
The debate has become more complicated following the introduction of a provisional measure signed by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on September 25.
The measure, identified as MP 1.394, suspends the operation, offering and advertising of sports betting and online games throughout Brazil.
Its implications have added another important constitutional and regulatory question to the Supreme Court's existing workload.
The measure is itself being challenged before the STF, meaning that the justices may need to consider not only the historical prohibition on gambling but also the legality and scope of the government's more recent intervention in the betting market.
The issue was also discussed in connection with a public hearing held one day before the November 4 court session. The hearing examined the impacts of the provisional measure and the broader consequences of online betting in Brazil.
Meanwhile, the joint committee in the National Congress responsible for examining the provisional measure had not yet been established at the time of the November 12 report.
This means that the measure's legislative scrutiny was still pending while its implications were already being debated in the judiciary.
The situation creates an unusual overlap between the executive, legislative and judicial branches, each of which has a role in determining the future of gambling regulation in Brazil.
Davi Alcolumbre extends the provisional measure's validity
Another significant development came from the Senate, where President Davi Alcolumbre extended the validity of the provisional measure for an additional 60 days.
The extension provides more time for Congress to examine the measure and determine its legislative future.
Taking into account the suspension of deadline calculations during the legislative recess, the measure could remain in force until March 2027.
This extension is particularly important for the gambling industry because it prolongs the period of uncertainty surrounding the regulatory status of sports betting and online gaming.
The possibility of the STF examining the provisional measure alongside the other gambling-related proceedings could further influence the timing and direction of the debate.
For operators, suppliers and other participants in Brazil's betting market, the combination of judicial proceedings and pending legislative decisions means that the future regulatory environment remains difficult to predict.
Background: The original Supreme Court proceedings and the position of Luiz Fux
The case returned by Dino is formally identified as Extraordinary Appeal RE 966177, which addresses the constitutional validity of the prohibition on gambling under Article 50 of the 1941 Misdemeanours Act.
The case originated from a dispute involving the operation of slot machines in a bar in São Leopoldo, in the Brazilian state of Rio Grande do Sul.
The individual concerned had initially been convicted, but a state-level appeals panel overturned the conviction, reasoning that the prohibition was incompatible with the constitutional framework established in 1988.
The Public Prosecutor's Office of Rio Grande do Sul subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court, seeking recognition that the relevant provision of the 1941 legislation had been incorporated into the new constitutional order and therefore remained enforceable.
When the STF began examining the case in August, rapporteur Luiz Fux voted in favour of maintaining the prohibition.
Fux argued that gambling restrictions could be justified by the need to protect individuals, their financial resources, their health and broader social welfare.
He also highlighted the psychological mechanisms associated with gambling, particularly the tendency of individuals who have suffered losses to continue betting in the hope of recovering their money.
According to Fux, gambling can involve what he described as a structure of seduction, encouraging players to continue participating even after losing.
He warned:
“This incapacity can be intensified and taken to the extreme by the way betting operates and functions, which requires increased attention from public authorities and the State.”
Fux also argued that constitutional guarantees of individual freedom do not necessarily provide an unrestricted right to engage in activities that may be harmful to personal health and well-being.
He maintained that fundamental rights are not absolute and that lawmakers can establish restrictions where competing public interests justify intervention.
His position was that the prohibition under the 1941 legislation remained constitutionally valid.
Dino broadly agreed with Fux on the continued validity of the prohibition but differed over the scope of the legal ruling. He believed the court should also address the modern betting industry and its associated risks.
He argued that it would be inconsistent to examine traditional gambling activities without considering the expansion of online betting platforms.
Dino also proposed a broader framework involving taxation, the use of part of gambling-related revenues to finance healthcare measures addressing gambling addiction, restrictions on advertising directed at children and adolescents, and prohibitions on algorithms designed to encourage compulsive gambling behaviour.
Fux was reluctant to extend the judgment into areas covered by separate legal proceedings, arguing that doing so could take the court beyond the specific subject of the appeal.
This disagreement ultimately contributed to Dino's request for additional time in August and his proposal to examine the related cases together.
The court's August proceedings were suspended by consensus, with the justices agreeing that the case should be considered alongside other gambling-related disputes.
The significance of RE 966177 extends beyond the original case. According to the Supreme Court, its eventual ruling could affect at least 2,728 cases currently suspended across Brazil's judicial system.
The decision could therefore establish an important precedent for how lower courts handle similar disputes involving the criminal classification of gambling operations.
What happens next?
With Dino having returned the proceedings to the STF on November 12, the responsibility for determining the next steps now rests with the court's leadership.
President Edson Fachin will have to decide when the case should return to the agenda and whether it should be considered separately or as part of a broader examination of gambling-related disputes.
The possibility of a joint hearing has gained support from several justices, including Dino, Toffoli and Fux, although additional time may be required to prepare comprehensive legal opinions covering the different cases.
The main issues potentially facing the court include:
Traditional gambling: Whether Article 50 of the 1941 Misdemeanours Act remains compatible with the 1988 Constitution.
Online betting: How the constitutional framework should apply to digital sports betting and online gaming.
Municipal lotteries: Whether municipalities have the authority to establish and operate their own lottery services, including sports-related products.
The provisional measure: Whether MP 1.394, which suspends sports betting and online gaming operations, offerings and advertising, is constitutionally valid.
Public health and consumer protection: Whether gambling regulation should incorporate stronger safeguards against addiction, compulsive behaviour and advertising directed at vulnerable groups.
No date has yet been announced for the resumption of the proceedings.
The return of the case therefore does not mean that the Supreme Court has reached a final decision on gambling's legal status in Brazil. Rather, it removes the procedural obstacle created by Dino's request for additional review and allows the court's leadership to organise the next stage of the process.
A potentially decisive moment for Brazil's gambling industry
Dino's decision to release RE 966177 comes at a particularly sensitive time for Brazil's gambling sector.
The country is facing several overlapping legal and political disputes concerning the operation of gambling businesses, the regulation of sports betting, online gaming, municipal lotteries and the government's authority to impose restrictions on the industry.
The possibility of a coordinated Supreme Court examination could provide a more comprehensive constitutional framework for addressing these questions.
At the same time, the provisional measure's extended validity and the absence of a confirmed hearing date mean that uncertainty is likely to persist in the immediate future.
For the gambling industry, the eventual outcome of the proceedings could have consequences extending well beyond the original dispute over the 1941 legislation. It could influence the interpretation of gambling prohibitions, the limits of government intervention, the powers of municipalities and the regulatory principles governing Brazil's expanding digital betting market.
The immediate development is procedural rather than a change in the law: Dino has released the case for consideration, but the STF has yet to determine when or how it will deliver its ruling.
By fLEXI tEAM





Comments